Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Eyeliner - Caribbean Sea - Smudge-Proof, Longwear, Creamy Gel - Sharpenable Eyeliner

This is the BEST eyeliner I have ever had! It was originally given to me as a gift. Since then I have reordered this Mally stick. It has staying power and the color does not fade or easily come off! It is easy to apply and is forgiving of mistakes.

perfect

This is a great color. I'm in my 60's I like to use makeup that is easy to use but also last long. I also like to use a color that accents my eyes. I might be 60+ (actually I'm 68) :-) but I still like to look good. These colors are in-depth but not harsh. they do not slide off the lower lid onto my cheek, as I have experienced before. Mallay is a great brand and the colors are soft and enhance my eyes not make them stand out or look like I'm using Clown makeup 💄.

This pencil is not the automatic one. The seller disclosed that but I like the Mally eye products enough that I took a chance on the one that needs manual sharpening. Right out of the box during first use the tip of the pencil broke when I was barely using any pressure. I would gladly buy Mally's retractable eyeliner but not the one needing manual sharpening. However, that said, the quality of the Mally product is not the seller's issue, but the rather manufacture's.

I've used only this product for years. Tried others but ended up throwing them away. Glides on, stays 24 hrs if you need it & doesn't smudge. Best I've ever used & would panic if I couldn't get it

It is one of the best eyeliners on the market!

Wrong color sent. Need Onyx

I bought this because my other pencil eyeliner kept coming off on the eyelash curler. This definitely has more staying power. it does not smudge or come off on the curler. I ordered the graphite color -- still very intense. I found that it was east to control and could make a thinner or thicker line easily. If you do it right away, you can even smudge it for a more easy look, but you have to do it pretty quickly after applying since it dries quickly. I use micellar water to remove and then follow up with a some lid foaming cleanser I have. It does stick at the base of the lashes sometimes though even after removing it at the end of the night.