365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Peanut Butter, Stir and Enjoy, 16 Ounce

Best peanut butter on the market: non-GMO, two ingredients, great price for size and tastes great. My favorite is the crunchy! Very healthy without alk the extra unnecessary ingredients. Spreads easily without stirring.

The peanut butter tasted delicious and fresh. However, it has a lot of oil and will require serious mixing. I put it in a larger container to do this because it runs out over the sides as you mix it in the jar it came in. I like it on crackers with a small amount of honey-butter. I do not recommend using it to make sandwiches for children to take to school because I think it will run out of sandwich and make a mess by lunchtime.

This peanut butter was horrendous, it was so bad that it's almost funny! When I opened it, it came splashing out of the container all over my kitchen counters. It's about the consistency of chocolate milk. It's supposed to be creamy but it's not. While it isn't "chunky," it has very large pieces all throughout that can get caught on a strainer. The good note is that it's so watery, that it WILL go through a strainer and that's not normal for peanut butter. I bought this brand for preschool projects, not for a food item and it could not be used. The kids were making peanut butter pine cone bird feeders but the peanut butter is so thin that it won't even stock to the pinecones. The consistency and texture were so bad that I would NEVER eat this product...and I will never use it for a craft project again. Absolutely the worst I've ever encountered. (I did stir what was left after it came splashing out of the jar. I'm aware that oil can pool on the surface, but this looked exactly like it had been taken out of a blender.) If zero stars were an option, I would have chosen that lol!

I’ve tried a lot of peanut butter brands, and this one is decent. The texture is super creamy and spreads easily, which I love. It also has a nice roasted peanut flavor that works great on toast or in smoothies. However, it’s a bit sweeter than I expected, and I prefer something more natural-tasting. Also, the jar is smaller than I thought for the price. Still, it’s convenient with no stirring needed and no oil separation. If you like sweet, smooth peanut butter, this could be a great choice—just not my personal favorite!

I’ve been buying this peanut butter for a while now, and it’s become a regular in my kitchen. Yes, you do have to stir it when you first open it—but honestly, that’s a small price to pay for how good it tastes. It’s really creamy, smooth, and has a nice, rich peanut flavor without being too sweet. I mostly use it on toast, in sandwiches, or just with apple slices, and it’s great every time. It also works well in baking and sauces. Once you stir it and keep it in the fridge, the texture stays nice and thick. No weird aftertaste, no overly oily feeling—just good, simple peanut butter.

A peanut butter than badly needs to be stirred. Peanut oil looks to have the consistency of water. Solids are densely compacter to the center of the jar. Difficult to stir. Peanut butter is a little too salty for my taste. Overall flavor is similar to other unsweetened brands - not the best, not the worst. I might give this brand another try, unsalted this time.

Just peanuts + a little salt no hydro, sugar etc. Great value and tastes wonderful. Easy on digestion if you like PB. Prime ships fast. Very fresh, sealed, best PB quaity I can find.

I love this peanut butter. It is the best crunchy peanut butter I’ve found without added sugar or hydrogenated oils. My only complaint is that Amazon seems to have a hard time keeping it in stock. Other observation: Folks. Seriously. It’s oily because it doesn’t have hydrogenated oils (the unhealthy oils) to thicken it at room temperature. So yes it is going to be runny at first. Stir it. Well. With a long knife or spoon. Like use some muscle and get the settled parts down at the bottom. Then put it in the refrigerator and keep it there. If you are expecting JIF, get JIF. Also, the crunchy “white pieces” are ground peanut pieces…not bugs. Seriously? You bought crunchy peanut butter. Seeing comments like this makes me wonder how we’ve survived this long as a species.