




desertcart.com: Roman Lives: A Selection of Eight Roman Lives (Oxford World's Classics): 9780199537389: Plutarch, Waterfield, Robin, Stadter, Philip A.: Books Review: Nice Plutarch Translation - I was looking for a readable Plutarch that didn't compromise the integrity of the work, and heard of Waterfield's translation on the Simply Charlotte Mason site. I was frustrated with other translations, that were hard to read and frustrating to my kids and me in our homeschool. The language here is challenging yet understandable. I like the divisions within each life, which make it easy to read small sections throughout the school year. This book enables teachers to cover Plutarch without fear. I wanted to pull my hair out before! I simply pre-read the numbered section (which I recommend, as some topics are very mature), then read it aloud to my children. We make a list of things we remember about the particular man were studying. My 5th and 6th grade girls (and I!) actually enjoyed reading about Cato this year. I encourage those of you who want to teach Plutarch but are afraid or apprehensive: try this version! Review: Absolutely fascinating - This is an outstanding translation of a great book. I love all of Plutarch's books but this one may be my favorite. The Oxford edition also has lots of explanatory notes and supplementary information; anyone with an interest in ancient Rome should read this work.


| ASIN | 0199537380 |
| Best Sellers Rank | #42,132 in Books ( See Top 100 in Books ) #10 in Reference & Collections of Biographies #27 in Ancient Greek History (Books) #53 in Ancient Roman History (Books) |
| Customer Reviews | 4.7 4.7 out of 5 stars (219) |
| Dimensions | 7.7 x 1.3 x 5 inches |
| Edition | Reissue |
| ISBN-10 | 9780199537389 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-0199537389 |
| Item Weight | 14.4 ounces |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 608 pages |
| Publication date | March 15, 2009 |
| Publisher | Oxford University Press |
J**E
Nice Plutarch Translation
I was looking for a readable Plutarch that didn't compromise the integrity of the work, and heard of Waterfield's translation on the Simply Charlotte Mason site. I was frustrated with other translations, that were hard to read and frustrating to my kids and me in our homeschool. The language here is challenging yet understandable. I like the divisions within each life, which make it easy to read small sections throughout the school year. This book enables teachers to cover Plutarch without fear. I wanted to pull my hair out before! I simply pre-read the numbered section (which I recommend, as some topics are very mature), then read it aloud to my children. We make a list of things we remember about the particular man were studying. My 5th and 6th grade girls (and I!) actually enjoyed reading about Cato this year. I encourage those of you who want to teach Plutarch but are afraid or apprehensive: try this version!
S**D
Absolutely fascinating
This is an outstanding translation of a great book. I love all of Plutarch's books but this one may be my favorite. The Oxford edition also has lots of explanatory notes and supplementary information; anyone with an interest in ancient Rome should read this work.
T**F
True Classic
I've heard of Plutarch's Lives as one of the books, along with the Bible, that many pioneers took with them when they went west. I imagine them saying to themselves as they're planning what absolute necessities can fit in their wagon, "If I can only take two books, which ones would I take?" And this was their answer. I've read the Greek Lives, and now I'm reading the Romans'. I must admit I've only read the first Roman Life, Cato the Elder, but it gave much food for thought. Plutarch is not necessarily rated G for young kids, but then again I can't think of any young person these days who could handle the deep subjects, advanced vocabulary, and archaic style. Personally, I find it fascinating. Since I taught World History to middle schoolers a couple of years ago, I'm clued in to some of the settings, social forces, and military struggles that were going on back then. That really enriches my reading, so if you're into history, this book is for you. When I decide to read Plutarch again, and I know I will, I want to read his entire set (this book only has the most well-known eight), the way he originally wrote it -- with a Greek life juxtaposed with a Roman life. (Got that from reading the Intro, which was very informative) Some books are meant to be digested; this is one of them.
T**U
One of my favorite books ever!
If you love good story telling, ancient tales and learning from how influential figures lived their lives, this book is for you. The translation is superb and very consistent throughout the book, reading this it feels like Plutarch is a native speaker who lives in this century! The book itself is incredibly fun. My favorite biographies are Sulla, Marius, Caesar and Mark Antony and the Gracchi brothers, though the other ones are just as good. One thing I really enjoy about this movie is that Plutarch included all the omens that these figures experienced before major events. These could easily be dismissed by the modern reader as superstitions or just made up dramatic effect, but these people tend to be much more connected to reality than we are. But who knows, I'm just a dude on the internet! Great book, and definitely one of the best books I ever read.
T**D
Good English Edition of Plutarch, but End Notes Distract the Reader
I read this English edition of Plutarch's Lives as part of my journey through the Western canon. My rating and this review are not of Plutarch himself, but of this English edition. As a note, OWC divides Plutarch's Lives into three editions: Greek Lives, Hellenistic Lives, and Roman Lives. This review is for OWC's Roman Lives. First, Philip Stadter writes an excellent introduction to Plutarch and the Roman lives covered in this edition. He demonstrates that Plutarch wrote the Parallel Lives not to provide a true historical record of each man but to provide moral instruction from the virtues or vices each man exhibited. Second, Robin Waterfield's English translation is excellent. It is clear, concise, and accessible. Third, Stadter's notes are brief but provide helpful explanations of the text. However, they are end notes and not footnotes. End notes require the reader to constantly flip back-and-forth in the book. Footnotes are much preferred. Because of the use of end notes instead of footnotes, I've given this good English edition of Plutarch 4-out-of-5 stars.
J**S
Good book. Awesome contents.
Roman Lives is much-better written than Greek Lives. Greek lives reads more like mythology than Roman Lives.
T**N
Great transaction and product!
Bought this book for a class and am so glad I did! Very informative and easy to read!
D**E
Wonderfully Up to Date Version of a Classic
This is a very easy to read translation of Plutarch's classic work. Nice cover. Clear printing. Well bound. If you haven't read these short works on the Greeks and Romans, you should. There is much to learn from their triumphs and their failures. For future leaders, scholars and politicians, much can be learned from those who came before. Recommended. (As well as, Greek Lives)
M**K
Travel back in time to the years of Rome's ascendancy in the Mediterranean, the fall of the Republic, and the rise of Empire. It is through the eyes of the principal actors on the scene that we witness the most momentous of events in Late Republican Rome. We meet Cato the Elder, famous for quipping that "Carthage must be destroyed, " and Aemilius Paullus who brought Macedon to heel. Next come the Gracchi brothers, both of them infamous for their appeals to the plebeians in their struggle with the Senatorial oligarchy, and for the extreme cost they both paid. Hysteria sweeps Rome as Germanic tribes invade Italy, and the people call to Marius for aid. Vying with Sulla for command of the Mithridatic war, we see crazed competition morph into Civil War and bloody proscriptions. You want more? Pompey's life features a slave revolt, the crushing of pirates, and a dramatic expansion of boundaries as more lands are turned into Roman provinces. Not to be outdone, Gaius Julius Caesar climbs the magisterial offices and wins profitable commands in his quest for prestige. When he said he'd "rather be first in a village than second in Rome" he obviously meant it. Discontent with dictatorship, a cohort of republican senators assassinate Caesar, who - like the republic itself - convulses in his twilight moments. Ushering in the Liberators' civil war, and the subsequent struggle between Mark Antony and Octavian, the tumult reaches its apex with Augustus as Emperor, and a sigh of relief among the Roman people. Great translation, and endlessly gripping. . .more than two thousand years later we get to read all about it.
P**L
Pleasent reading of previous lives. You might learn a lesson or 2.
B**R
Conteúdo ok, um clássico bem traduzido e organizado. Empacotamento horrível - sem selagem à vácuo em plástico protetor, só um livro dentro da embalagem de papel padrão amazon viajando entre dois continentes. As manchas pretas estavam pelo menos dois tons mais escuras, eu esfreguei com um pano umidecido. Inaceitável para um livro vendido como novo.
S**6
Great view on historical events from an ancient historian.
J**K
It is incredible to jump to this period and to see Plutarch's interesting albeit controversial interpretation of the events through history. The people chosen are fairly close to his time and the writings skill brilliantly captures the characteristics and personalities of the individuals that you would otherwise be unable to see and makes these huge figures of history much more human and thus inspiring or dare say repulsing depending on how you take it on yourself. With that in mind, I'd definitely recommend giving this a read if it's something you don't mind spending time reading!
Trustpilot
3 weeks ago
2 months ago