Chofit28mm Width Band Keeper Compatible with Garmin Vivoactive HR/Forerunner 910XT Fastener Loops Replacement Band Holder Compatible with Fitbit Surge Bands, 6 Pack

Returned because they were too wide, but they looked good.

I purchased these to replace the band keeper on my Garmin Vivoactive HR. The fit is perfect and the little nubbin keeps the loose end of the band from slipping out, just like the original.There are many sellers for this item. Are they all made in the same factory and sold by different companies? Who knows. I purchased these because they were $1 cheaper than the 10-pack from another seller and they were located in a warehouse closer to me, so the predicted (and actual) date I got them was faster by 5 days. I won't ever use 10 of them. Heck, I won't ever use all 6, so I'm fine with the fact that per unit, these cost more. I still saved $1. Woo-hoo!Many reviews for OTHER SELLERS of the seemingly same item complain that the nubbin is on the wrong face of the band keeper. Thus, the band keeper is "upside down." Yep, it sure looks like the flat side of the keeper with the square edges should go against your skin with the rounded edge facing out. Its just a nicer look. Ah, but look again at your OEM original from Garmin. It is shaped exactly the same way. The flat side with the square edges faces out on the original also. The square edges on my original weren't quite so squared off, but perhaps they had just worn away. Anyway, this isn't upside down, but is designed like the original. That applies to the other sellers' products as well, assuming the pictures match the product and the complainer's descriptions.As for size, I had to stretch this over the clasp. If you aren't careful, I suppose it could break when installing it on the band, but mine didn't come close to that. I like that because the keeper fits perfectly on the band. Some reviews for other sellers say that the keeper is slightly loose on the band. Perhaps that is done so the item doesn't have to stretch over the clasp. (Hmm, maybe the others really are made in a different factory?) I like the fact that this fits perfectly on the band after stretching it over the clasp.I've only had it for a day, so I can't say anything about longevity, but it seems to be well made.It's a keeper! (Ouch! Sorry!)

Works great Don't have to buy a new watch band.

Good

This does not work for the Garmin Forerunner 645 watch band. It is to big and slides right off the band