Crumps' Naturals Beef Liver Bites For Pets, 4.8-Ounce

These are the perfect size and a better value size bag than you find in stores. I like that they are cubed too so when we were leash training and I only had one hand to grab I could easily pick up one or two without struggle. He was very reactive and these treats were yummy enough to refocus him in some situations (reactive dog parents will get it). Also work in snuffle mats and puzzles nicely

My dogs loved ii. I will buy it again

I like that my dog loves these and he basically hovers attentively the whole walk waiting for them. If he's off leash somewhere and he knows that I have them, he comes back very quickly when I call him.He's a hunting dog so his nose leads first so that can be really difficult, (recall), but you also want to let him have the space to run and smell some days. These treats just make it a little more convincing for him to come back over to me.They are bite size, low in calories, and grain free because it's liver so it's a lot easier on his stomach than past treats we've tried.

I have a Chihuahua mix who is very fussy when it comes to dog treats, so it was nice to find something she will eat. I like that they are a single ingredient treat made in the USA, with USA beef liver. They aren’t hard like a crunchy treat, because they are dehydrated, so easy for small breeds to eat. My dog gets a treat every time she comes in from going potty, and since buying these, she will want to go outside about 20 minutes later, but won’t do anything, and then come in and wait for a treat, lol. They are so smart!I give her 3-4 each time, but I know she would eat the whole bag at once if given the chance. I would recommend these for any dog, especially picky eaters.

Got these for training my dog. She loves them and they're small and on the healthier side so I don't have to worry about her gaining weight in the process. Win, win.