Better Butter Thinking Putty®

This is the best putty ever!! It’s not too oily, never dries out, isn’t sticky, and is so so soft!! it’s much easier to handle compared to crazy Aaron’s over putty’s. It has a perfect stretch, and a very sweet smell like popcorn. It’s fun and very yellow! 100% recommend, I’m going to get the other colors as well!!

Very good. Not sticky, smells just like butter!

I have a bunch of Aarons Putty. This one is definitely the smoothest one (feels great!). Im so used to the 3.2 oz (90g) so this one did caught me by suprise when I held it in my hands (smaller amount of putty than what im used to). I didnt realize it was only 2.1 oz (60g). But it doesnt change my opinion on the product itself. Very smooth, requires less strength from your hands to play with, and definitely a great stress putty. It even has a sweet buttery scent to it (not overpowering either). Im curious if they have a 3.2oz, if they dont, I kind of get why. This is very smooth/silky so having to handle more than the 2.1oz would kind of be too much for me to handle. I feel like it would be all over my hands and I wouldnt be able to enjoy it as much if it did come in a 3.1oz. So im actually ok with it being a smaller amount! If you're an Aarons putty kind of person, this is a nice addition to your collection! I would definitely recommend this to a person who's into slime too. Also the packaging can be messy when you first open the tin (all aarons tins are like this), but once you collect all the gooeyness with the putty itself, itll be nice and clean. And if anybody is curious, I store all of my Aaron's putty in a belt storage/organizer i also got on amazon!

Gave this to my 10 yr old. She loves the texture of this putty, which is very different from the others we have had. Sooooo smooth and buttery. A friend did come over and played with it and smashed it into her jeans. Obviously, this is something that needs to be addressed with kids before allowing to play with it. It is very difficult to get out of fabric if pressed into it, so I would only give it to a kid who can follow boundaries with it.

This may be my favorite Crazy Aaron’s putty. The texture is soft and smooth and the smell is amazing. It’s hard to put down!

I've been looking for a putty that acts like a slime and this is the closest i've gotten. It's very fun to play with when you want something to do with your hands while watching or whatever. It's very smooth, very buttery, and very stress relieving. The only flaw with it is how "oily" it is. I get that it's meant to be like butter--scent and all. But the oily-ness is throwing me off a bit. It doesn't get on your hands, so that's a plus. Another thing, videos on Tiktok show that this makes a lot of "popping" noises like slime does. It doesn't. Even if i fluff it up, it doesn't make as much popping noises as slime does. So if you're looking for a putty that gives great pops...this ain't it. Overall, it's great. Would buy again if there is a different option than butter.

Actually incredible. Much better than slime since it doesn’t dry out and feels great to play with.

Very smooth. Similar to the other putties, but softer.

It’s so soft and it feels so good

This stuff feels absolutely INCREDIBLE!!

Like it

This feels soooo good but be careful cuz i heard if you played with it for a while it will melt but ut never happened for me but I recommend it

Pretty good