Best Pet Flap XL Replacement Dog Door Flap Compatible with Ideal Pet Products Ruff Weather - Measures 9.75" x 17" Longer Lasting, Most Energy Efficient, Less Shrinkage, BPA Free

After trying a couple of others from companies that used to work this one actually still fits well enough to be effective against the weather and connect with the magnets quickly and evenly. Thank goodness! I also appreciate that the material is softer than other replacement doors I've tried.

It took me all of 5 minutes (if even that!) to remove the old worn out warped flap on my IDEAL XL pet door, and replace with this one! It is perfect fit! It lines up perfectly to catch the magnetic strip. And even better in my opinion is that THIS flap is actually not clear (see through) which is exactly what I prefer, because I do not like the sunlight shining in through the pet door. My only disappointment is the price. There are other replacement flaps that have 2 packs for this price or cheaper, but I did actually go with this because I didn’t want the see through clear flaps. I actually have a double flap pet door and now seeing how good the fit is and being satisfied that it will help block out the light more, I will order another one for the second flap I need to replace. I cannot speak for the durability of it as of yet, but I do notice the material is not as thick as the flaps as the originals. I hope they hold up. The originals lasted for almost 18 years. I’m not expecting that, but I won’t be happy if these only last a few months. Time will tell. At this point though I am super happy with the flap!

It actually IS the best pet flap replacement. I compared it with another after-market flap, and this one was more true to size for my dog door (both long enough to not let in wind, and wide enough to catch on the fuzzy weatherstripping on the sides). Plus, the screw holes were carefully placed, unlike the other brand, so it was much easier to install. The metal plate at the bottom catches the magnet, and I like that it is opaque. It's a good weight and flexibility, similar to the original flap, and my dog went through it no problem (although I'm sure he wondered where all the dirty smears from his old one went...). I hope that it lasts as long as my last one did (17 years with numerous big dogs!).

Great fit, great quality! I wish that I had noticed that they are not see through!

These XL flaps fit well for my RuffWeather XL dog door. They have maybe 1/8 inch gap at the bottom, but so have all the previous flaps. The magnetic strength isn't super strong but enough to hold the flaps in place. These are a little thicker than previous flaps. I did not realize these are frosted rather than clear. Not a problem, just different than what we have been using. Price was fair and much better than on official website. Shipping was delayed by three days by carrier for unknown reason but was not a problem as it wasn't an immediate need. Hopefully the thicker flaps will hold up better. As for weatherproofing, time will tell. We get some strong winds that blow in the flaps, I expect the same will occur with these too since the magnetic strength on my door vs the gap is not super strong. Previous flaps have stretched and the strength of magnet hold improved, maybe that will occur again. Overall, price vs expectations are met. I will buy again from this seller.

We have a RuffWeather XL doggy door. According to the brand themselves, you need a 9.75 inch x 17.5 inch flap. That is simply not true. I know because I bought that exact measurement and they were too short. You need a 9.75 inch x 18 inch flap, which this IS. I am not joking when I say I have tried 4 different brands and types to get a good fit for our doggy door, resorting to manually shaving the sides of the last pair of flaps to make them a better fit because I was so sick and tired of ordering and returning those that didn't fit.....but now I have found these, I am saving them in my list in case I need them again. These.....fit....PERFECTLY! And I mean absolutely perfectly. So if you have a RuffWeather XL doggy door and you're looking for replacement flaps, congratulations.....you've found them! Also, these are opaque and not clear. It's of no importance, but you might want to know that.

Fits fairly well in our dog door, but the magnet is either not as strong as the previous or it just doesn't seal as well. There's always gaps cause it doesn't seamlessly close. THe screws don't last either, if you have dogs that bolt out the dog door like mine, you'll have to replace the screws cause they just come loose. Fine for what I paid

Perfect replacement for our dog door. Seals perfectly with the magnets and looks great! Great value instead of having to buy an entire new unit.

It is so hard to find the right size for large door flaps. These fit exactly with holes that go over plastic pegs for screws. Installation is a breeze. Fits perfectly. Fast delivery to Canada. Totally recommend them.

Fit & true to size. Fairly quick delivery

Sturdy, frosted finish and fit the door it's intended for perfectly!