Old Fashioned Mary Jane Wrapped Taffy Candy (2 Pound)

If you’re into retro sweets that take you back to simpler times, Mary Jane Wrapped Taffy Candy is a total blast from the past. These chewy little treats blend molasses and peanut butter, giving you that sweet combo that’s both nostalgic and oh-so-satisfying.Individually wrapped, they’re perfect for sharing—or, let’s be honest, for sneaking a few when no one’s looking (we won’t judge). The texture might be a bit sticky, but hey, that’s part of the charm, right? You get the feeling you’re really working for that delicious peanut butter hit.It’s like the candy version of a family reunion—familiar, comforting, and a bit sticky, but in the best way possible. If you’re craving a taste of old-school candy, Mary Jane Taffy hits the spot every time.

The shape has changed over the years. This has been one of my favorite caddies since I was a child.The flavor has changed a tad, but I'm not complaining.They now taste between a Bit-O-Honey and the black & orange Halloween Cady.I Love, love this product.

We ordered these for a trick or treat bar but could not bring ourselves to put them out. First off, they are not the Mary Janes you might remember. They are small, thin, with no peanut butter flavor. Also, this batch was so hard to chew that we were afraid guests would lose a filling. Lastly, the wrappers were dripping with grease, so when you unwrapped them, it left grease on your fingers. A hard "no" on these (no pun intended)!

I loved them, but this time there seemed to be much oil in and outside of the individual wrappers.

Real peanut butter taste, great value only negative they arrived and the wrappers have an oily feeling.

Was very disappointed. The pieces were way too small, not like I use to buy

TASTY CANDY

No, they don’t have a layer of peanut butter I would say they’re sort of an adult version of Mary Jane in a little roll. Like if salt water taffy got denser and richer. Uniform in flavor, they’re roasted peanutty with a dash of molasses. A very tasty chew.