Velvet Eyeliner (HUNTERGREEN & LA FRESH Makeup Remover Wipes (10). WATERPROOF PEN, dries on contact with precision tip that stays on ALL DAY with NO SMUDGING, SMEARING, FADING OR PULLING & clump-free

I looked forward to receiving this eyeliner and am very disappointed. It does not work! I have tried and used many expensive brands ie Bobbi Brown etc. from the Sephora website and all of them performed the way eyeliner should!! I ordered the brown and perhaps that is part of the reason it is light but I cannot use this at all. It simply does not work except for a very faint line. I also do not like the entire product including the pencil applicator. Cheap.How often does this product need to be applied during the day???? What kind of question is that????? The correct answer should be once and done for the day.

This eyeliner is quite a bargain. Comes with make up remover wipes that alone are worth the price. The eyeliner is very easy to apply with a skinny brush, and easier than usual to remove. Makes a fine line. I keep buying more expensive ones that make heavier lines but I mess them up and keep coming back to this one. This is the third one I’ve bought. I guess it’s the one for me!

This eyeliner is amazing! I've been looking for a smudge-proof eyeliner for a long time that easy time apply. It's also easy off with my cosmetic remover wipes. I will never buy anything else. If you like a cat-eye, it does a great one!

I love this eyeliner. I’ve been Using it for about 7 years, and nothing can compare to it. So sad the brand couldn’t correct a few issues it had and make it better, this is why it might already been out of the market and just few pieces left. I need this item for ever

Nice eyeliner remover

I like the smoothness of brush, it is good to even draw thin line but it last for 7-8 use...I wonder I received used one! 12.99 for 7-8 use not worth.

DO NOT BUY THIS PRODUCT!!! This is the worst eyeliner I have ever used. It is a complete waste of money. I ordered the Charcoal and it is so light that it's almost invisible, if one can even put it on one's eyes. I am throwing it in the garbage and there goes $12.99 without a single use! It's shameful that this product is even on the market. I would not give this product any stars at all, but apparently Amazon requires at least one. That should not be allowed.

I personally was dissatisfied!! Wasn't going to leave feed back but since review email kept coming I figured I would. The eyeliner had to get thrown right in the garbage was all dried up. Not so sure it was a new product not being in packaging so for me it was a waste of money.