essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Tubing Mascara, Black, Smudge-proof (Pack of 1) | No Flaking, Washes Off with Warm Water, Volumizing & Lengthening; Vegan, Cruelty Free, Paraben-Free, Oil-Free

This mascara WORKS! It goes on nicely. It does not smudge or run. It's easy to remove. And it's a great price. I've tried various brands over the years, but now this is the only mascara I buy.

I usually have five or six mascaras going at once because I like different ones for different looks. This has become my new go to when I want just a simple lightweight mascara. I have very sensitive eyes and they get irritated a lot especially if it's a mascara that flakes at all. This one does not flake and it does not smudge . I will continue to buy this. It was a perfect replacement for another mascara from another brand that I'm no longer supporting.

4 stars. I don’t have any problem with this mascara. It’s cheap, it’s black, it seems to be tubing. I really can’t complain considering the price, but I will say, the name is a bit misleading. It doesn’t totally eliminate smudging, but mainly I just get flaking. I often discover small mascara flakes under my eyes, especially when I put this on my bottom lashes. It doesn’t slide off nicely like I’ve seen other tubing mascara do. I’m not a seasoned mascara wearer, and the best mascara I’ve ever used was a free sample of a very expensive brand, the name of which escapes me. This mascara does seem to have a pretty thick goopy consistency, but it isn’t clumpy or lumpy. I feel like it’s actually pretty easy to work with. It’s easy to control the amount of product I put on my lashes, and it’s very buildable. It doesn’t add any obvious length to my lashes beyond any average mascara. I only apply it to the mids and ends of my lashes, and I don’t feel like it drags them down too badly at all. I always thoroughly curl my lashes before applying, and the curl lasts well. Overall, I like it.

Looks good when applied and comes off easy but doesn't last long-- it doesn't appear to flake or but does smudge slightly and it is barely noticeable after a couple hours. Also I have used many tubing formulas and this does not act like one-- doesn't go on like one and doesn't come off like one.

Absolutely essence mascaras. This is one of my favorites! And definitely doesn’t smear everywhere. Will be buying again!

I have never had a mascara that didn't smudge in SC summer humidity until this mascara. Love it!

I thought I was going to love this mascara, but unfortunately it let me down:/ it tends to be quite clumpy on the lashes, and it can flake off really easily leaving black flakes all under my eyes. It’s supposed to be a tubing mascara, but it doesn’t tube off, It just comes off like a regular mascara, which is a little bit disappointing, probably won’t be buying again, it also wasn’t lengthening.

The product itself is convenient because you can easily wash it off with water. However, it literally brings my lashes down. I have naturally long lashes and also get lash lifts, and this mascara doesn’t hold them up at all. If you’re looking for a mascara that’s easy to remove, then yes, it does a great job. But if you want to keep your lashes looking long and lifted, this is not it.

I have no idea if this mascara flakes or runs, because when I apply it, it doesn’t look like I’m wearing mascara at all, so I am forced to use a different mascara over the top. I have very fair lashes, so it’s odd to me that a black mascara would barely show up on my lashes. Maybe the tube is actually empty? who knows?!

Love this mascara! It doesn’t smudge at all. Really holds its own against the more expensive brands!

الفرشه مش حلوووه ابدا

If I could choose more stars I would, this mascara is amazing for moms.. Looks amazing all day, and washes off with ease.. major PLUSSS++++

En los personal me encantó porque se quita muy fácil con agua a diferencia de otros rímeles que se corren. No aporta tanto volumen y no deja las pestañas levantados por mucho tiempo.