JOAH Make Her Gel-ous Gel Eyeliner with Self-Sharpening Pencil, No-Tug Waterproof Formula & Long-Lasting Finish & Color Definition, Creamy Gel Texture, Blackest Black

Finally found the perfect eyeliner. It is easy to apply and is smudge proof and waterproof.

This is the best eyebrow crayons and eyeliner that I have every used!!! It stays on all day. Sometimes all night! I love it!

I like this eyeliner because it goes on smooth, it has a mechanical advance so you don't have to sharpen, and it is fairly waterproof although it will smudge sometimes. My main complaint is I ordered the 1 oz. size and what I received is the .017 oz. size. That is quite a difference in the amount of product. Has anyone actually received this product with 1 oz?

It is long lasting and glides on easily

I like JOAH products. I especially like that every JOAH product I've purchased in stores and online has come with a great tamper proof seal.I bought this eyeliner in Black but it does not glide on. It is much too dry for me to use on my eyelid. I tried to make it work by using a smudger to smooth it out but that did not work. I don't like tugging at my eye area.I like the tip though, so I tried to use it on my eyebrows but it's too dark for that.

This gel eyeliner in black is easy to apply and did not smudge during a very hot and humid day. I would prefer a thinner tip, but it was so easy to apply that I was able to make a good line on the first try. The price is very reasonable.I can’t say how long the gel will last before drying up. Probably depends on usage. Will buy again.

Tried and tried to line my eyes and nothing transferred toy lid. Gave one star because I couldn't give zero. Threw away the next day.

This pencil is easy to use, makes a clean line and looks great. It lasts for a long time and is easy to be smoothed for a softer line.