Tovolo Silicone Ice Cube Tray with Lid for Freezer Oyster Gray, Dishwasher Safe BPA Free Silicone Ice Cube Mold Tray with Cover, Easy Release 1 Inch Ice Cube for Coffee Cocktails Bourbon Whiskey

I am very happy with this. It is a little challenging getting the cubes out, but putting it upside down on the little storage unit I am using for ice cubes allows me to press them out into the container. I have kept on and gave one to a friend and she likes it too.

Makes perfect cube ice cubes.

I bought this tray instead of the traditional plastic one because I have some childhood memories of being unable to get the ice out of those. I was expecting a bendable silicone tray to be really easy to use. Just bend and *pop* ice comes out.This is not the case. You have to really push hard to get the ice out and it seems like you basically have to do it one-by-one. It's not terrible for my use-case (a glass of ice water or tea every now and then), but it would be impractical if I needed a lot of ice regularly.That said, the cubes this tray produces look really nice. They're perfect cubes and are a convenient size for a large cup.I've only used it 5 or 6 times so far, but I haven't detected the off flavor that others have described. I did get a rubbery/plastic flavor the very first time I used it, so maybe give it a wash first, though.

It’s great! I love the ice, I usually do two fill ups a day. One in the morning and one at night.

Perfect cubes for craft cocktails like Manhattan’s or Old Fashions. Would definitely buy again.

This mold makes perfectly square ice cubes as advertised and the lid is great to help keep any errant odors out. The cubes however are very difficult to remove, and I’ve tried several different methods.

When I was looking for a new ice tray my first thought was "I wonder what new and amazing shapes there are in ice tray technology. Turns out that after many trials and errors, good old fashioned Square offers the best ice shape you could ask for

I really wanted to love this ice cube tray. I saw some other reviews that said the lid didn’t fit snugly — it doesn’t — and the cubes were hard to remove — they are — but I thought maybe those reviewers were doing something wrong. If they were, so did I. I did not overfill the sections of the tray, but like most silicone ice cube trays, they are soft and when full, you have to hold them with both hands while they’re full of water. The lid did not in any way snap in place; you just sort of press it on and hope for the best. When I moved the tray, water leaked out, so I emptied some out so it wouldn’t be overfilled. I’ve noticed with any ice cube trays I’ve had with lids that it makes stacking easier, but it also takes longer for the ice cubes to freeze.I was very excited to see the cubes, but when I twisted the tray a little to loosen them, nothing happened. It was like they were Super Glued in the tray. Then I twisted harder. Still nothing. I turned the tray upside down and tried again. Nope. Then I started pressing the individual ice cube sections from the bottom trying to force the cubes out that way. I was able to get only a couple cubes out, and by then, my hands were freezing from gripping the tray so hard for so long.I put the lid back on, turned the tray over, and ran warm water on the bottom to try to melt the cubes enough to loosen them so they’d fall out. About one third of them came out. I wound up literally having to put more hot water on the tray bottom and then force the cubes out by pressing down hard on the individual sections until I pushed them inside out. The ice literally stuck in the trays.That is the absolute longest, time-consuming, multi-step process that left my hands freezing that I’ve ever gone through to get ice out of a tray. I used it once, and I won’t be using it again. I bought a similar set of trays that were delivered the same day made by another company and had exactly the same problem with them. Silicone seems like a good idea in theory, but there’s not much support when the tray is full of water and you have to fight to get the cubes out with both brands. Making ice shouldn’t be so difficult or time consuming. I can’t recommend this tray.

Me hubiera gustado el cubo de hielo más grande, pero aún así funciona. Fácil de sacar. Compré 2 piezas. Lo recomiendo.

Soaked the ice cube tray in vinegar/water solution for 30 min before using to get rid of the plastic smell. Ice cubes turn out great every time - no plastic smell or taste. Ice cubes are easy to remove so long as you don't fill the tray all the way to the top - leave about 2mm of space so that ice expands vertically instead of sideways.

Lid not tight at all. Will leak if not careful

Like the idea of its lid. However, it's not so easy to get the cube out... a bit disappointed about this as I spent more $ for this. And the much cheaper one I found at a local grocery store is easier to work with.

Only got one! How ridiculous. It’s advertised as a “set of two” in multiple places